Lawsuit filed over Jones Act
By TOM CALLIS
Tribune-Herald staff writer
A Honolulu attorney is challenging the Jones Act again in federal court.
John Carroll filed the class-action lawsuit Thursday on behalf of seven plaintiffs, including a Hilo businessman, who allege the maritime law encourages shipping monopolies and unfairly inflates prices for Hawaii consumers.
Carroll had lost a legal challenge of the act in 2009, seeking injunctive relief for his clients. A federal court judge dismissed the case saying he couldn’t prove a direct connection to the financial harm they suffered and the law.
“The main difference is that we do have the particularized basis for showing this,” he said. “And then also, I’m not asking for injunctive relief this time. I’m going to go right to trial.”
The case will be heard in the U.S. District Court of Hawaii. Carroll estimated a trial would take six to eight months to start.
The Jones Act requires all shipping vessels travelling between states to be American built, owned and manned.
Its critics say it causes economic harm to Hawaii, particularly dependent on ocean cargo, by in effect putting shipping in control of two companies: Matson and Horizon Lines. That lack of competition leads to higher prices, they argue.
James O’Keefe, one of the plaintiffs, wrote in an affidavit that rising shipping costs, which he partially attributed to limited shipping competition, helped put his Hilo bakery out of business.
“The Jones Act singles out Hawaii for disparate treatment in relation with other states,” the former owner of O’Keefe & sons, Bread Bakers wrote in the affidavit signed in 2009. The bakery went out of business in 2008.
“It was not the only factor in the demise (of the business) … but at an estimated additional cost of 7.5 percent of income, it was the most significant,” he wrote.
Carroll said the goal of the lawsuit is the repeal of the act, which he believes violates the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
“It’s like a revolution for Hawaii to throw off the chains of the oppressive U.S. government on this little single state with this stupid provision,” he said. “It’s just crazy.”
Carroll lost a bid for the Republican Senate nomination this year, and included repeal of the act as part of his platform.
Email Tom Callis at email@example.com.
Rules for posting comments
Comments posted below are from readers. In no way do they represent the view of Oahu Publishing Inc. or this newspaper. This is a public forum.
Comments may be monitored for inappropriate content but the newspaper is under no obligation to do so. Comment posters are solely responsible under the Communications Decency Act for comments posted on this Web site. Oahu Publishing Inc. is not liable for messages from third parties.
IP and email addresses of persons who post are not treated as confidential records and will be disclosed in response to valid legal process.
Do not post:
- Potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.
- Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
- Copyrighted materials of any sort without the express permission of the copyright holder.
- Personal attacks, insults or threats.
- The use of another person's real name to disguise your identity.
- Comments unrelated to the story.
If you believe that a commenter has not followed these guidelines, please click the FLAG icon below the comment.