Royce White, trailblazer for the mentally ill?
By CHRIS DUNCAN
AP Sports Writer
HOUSTON — Royce White may never make it in the NBA.
The Houston Rockets’ first-round draft pick might drift into anonymity as a role player, someone more familiar on the bench than on the court.
Yet no matter what path his career takes, he’s already built a legacy — as a fierce, outspoken advocate for the mentally ill and their legal rights in the workplace. In his case, that workplace is the highest level of professional basketball in the world.
White has general anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder and he’s finally back on the court after refusing to play for 2 1/2 months until he got special additions, or protocols, put in his contract to help him cope with his condition. The basis for White’s stand was the Americans with Disabilities Act, the federal law that requires employers to provide “reasonable accommodations” to employees with a physical or mental impairment.
White’s often contentious and very public dispute with his team culminated in late January with a unique (cut ‘written’) agreement that addresses White’s issues. White joined the Rockets’ developmental league affiliate two weeks ago to resume the career that got him all the attention in the first place.
“It was tough not being able to play,” White said, “but it was necessary.”
Lawyers say White’s campaign raises intriguing questions about how the ADA addresses mental illness in professional sports, and may provide a road map for other athletes to follow. Psychiatrists say White’s openness about his disorder has already helped lift the stigma of mental illness and may embolden other athletes to publicly acknowledge their afflictions.
In itself, an athlete dealing with mental illness is not a recent development.
Outfielder Jimmy Piersall famously coped with bipolar disorder in the 1950s, spending seven weeks in a mental hospital at one point. He returned to baseball, was twice named to the All-Star team and played in the majors until the late 1960s. Pitcher Zack Greinke almost quit baseball because of his social anxiety disorder, but learned to control it and was named the AL Cy Young award winner in 2009. Chicago Bears receiver Brandon Marshall has been named to four Pro Bowls despite an acknowledged borderline personality disorder. Retired NFL running back Ricky Williams won the Heisman Trophy at Texas and played 11 NFL seasons while dealing with social anxiety disorder.
The Rockets knew what they were getting when they selected White out of Iowa State with the 16th overall pick. White freely acknowledged his condition and issues in pre-draft interviews, including a fear of flying that triggered panic attacks. When he flew — or anticipated flying on the ride to the airport — his heart rate would speed up, he’d feel tingling in his extremities and he’d break into cold sweats.
After he was drafted, he flew to Las Vegas for the team’s summer-league games and to a rookie orientation in New York. As training camp approached, though, White began to have reservations about handling the demands of the NBA schedule. And it wasn’t just the intimidating itinerary of flights required during an NBA season. It was what White thought might happen if he didn’t address it promptly.
“If I’m stressed out, if I have an anxiety disorder that gets out of control,” he said in an interview in October, “how dangerous am I? So tackling it from the front is important. That’s what I kind of did, to take care of my own health first.”
He sat out the first week of training camp after asking for the special protocols, including permission to travel by bus on road trips. He also wanted an independent physician to have the final say about when he could play.
White argued that his mental illness was no different than a physical injury, and the law sees it the same way. But Alex Long, a University of Tennessee law professor who teaches disability law, said making “reasonable accommodations” for someone with a mental disorder is more challenging than providing for someone with a physical disability.
“In theory, the law treats both of those impairments the same way,” Long said. “If I’m in a wheelchair, it’s fairly easy for an employer to make modifications to the workplace. They can put in a ramp, they can widen the aisles or something like that.
“Mental impairments and what the employees are usually asking for, are basically changes to the rules and the normal ways of doing things,” Long said. “Those are the kinds of things that employers are particularly resistant to changing.”
The Rockets let White use a recreational vehicle and referred him to a prominent psychiatrist in Houston. Still, White left the team on Nov. 12 and called the team “inconsistent with their agreement to proactively create a healthy and successful relationship.”
The negotiations began again.
Marty Orlick, a San Francisco-based attorney who’s represented corporate clients in ADA cases, said the Rockets were obligated to provide accommodations, but didn’t have to allow an outside physician to determine White’s playing status. Orlick said White’s case could have “really significant” legal ramifications, even though it never ended up in a courtroom.
“Athletes should be treated the same way that any employee in any company should be treated,” Orlick said. “The fact they are high-profile celebrities, they’re still entitled to all the (ADA) protections.”
NBA Commissioner David Stern, in Houston last week for All-Star Weekend, said he was glad that White and the Rockets had reached an agreement, but said the publicity White generated — mostly via his Twitter account — probably delayed a resolution.
“We tend to deal with it in a quieter fashion than this one played out, as you might imagine,” Stern said.
One of White’s core arguments was that the NBA had no mental-health protocol and needs to draft one. Stern says the league has been handling situations involving the mental health of its players for years.
“The only thing that I sort of disagree with is that, when someone says, ‘Oh, this will be the first time that we’ve dealt with this situation,’” Stern said. “Of course it’s not.”
Three decades ago, the NBA did create an action plan when several players fell into illicit-drug use and addiction. In 1983, with Stern then working as the league’s executive vice president, the NBA and the players’ union crafted a policy that provides treatment and rehabilitation for players with substance-abuse issues.
Former NBA player John Lucas was right in the middle of what he calls the league’s “drug epidemic” with his own alcohol and cocaine abuse. He was one of the first players to acknowledge his addictions and turn to the NBA’s policy for help.
Like White, Lucas was a first-round pick by the Rockets. He now praises the NBA’s policy, considered revolutionary at the time.
“Back then, nobody knew what to do with me,” Lucas said. “Look where we’ve progressed. We don’t have those issues today.”
Lucas runs a well-known Houston-based program that provides substance-abuse counseling for athletes. He says he sees more players with mental illness than he did 10 or 20 years ago, and their symptoms are often minimized or untreated altogether.
“People don’t know what they’re dealing with, and it’s often just misdiagnosed as ADD (attention deficit disorder),” Lucas said. “Sometimes, other issues come up, and what happens then? The player is even more hesitant to come forward about it.”
Lucas already sees White’s agreement with the Rockets as “progress” for the league.
“Nobody knows how this is going to work,” Lucas said. “What has had to happen here is both sides had to find an approach that works. But in his case, if this is going to be your profession, then you have to find some solutions. And you can’t know what’s going to work until you try them.
“If anything, it’s made people aware of (mental illness),” Lucas said. “NBA players, we have lifelong issues, too. We’re no different than any other bozos on the bus. We just happen to play sports.”
According to the National Institute of Mental Health, about 26.2 percent of American adults meet criteria for a diagnosable mental disorder each year and, of those, about 18 percent have an anxiety disorder.
The Rockets haven’t commented publicly on White’s situation beyond written statements. Fans of the team are frustrated, believing that Houston wasted a first-round pick on a player who came with too much baggage.
But White also gets regular responses from Twitter followers who call him a hero and inspiration. Some admit they’re dealing with anxiety and other mental-health issues as well, and White is quick to respond, using hash tags like (hash)AnxietyTroopers and (hash)BeWell as personal signatures.
Toni Baum, a sports psychiatrist who has a private practice near Washington, D.C., and specializes in the treatment of athletes, said White’s openness is a pivotal step in lifting the stigma of mental illness in sports.
“It is something that, for them, amounts to a risk,” he said. “But what motivates them, I think, is they’re amazed by the help they’re able to get, once they put their story out there. Once they become convinced of that, I think they feel moved to share it with teammates and other people out there who might be suffering.”
Whether his basketball career ever pans out, White feels like he’s already made an impact on the cause that matters to him most.
“I think it’s all been real positive,” said White, who is currently assigned to the Rio Grande Valley Vipers in the NBA D-League. “I feel blessed and honored to be part of what has taken place the last two months, despite how tumultuous it might have seemed. It was a very progressive kind of thing and it needed to be done. And I appreciate the Rockets and the NBA being patient with such a new topic like mental health and now I’m moving forward.
“This isn’t the end or the beginning,” he said, “it’s just another piece and we’ll just try to do the best we can with it.”
Rules for posting comments
Comments posted below are from readers. In no way do they represent the view of Oahu Publishing Inc. or this newspaper. This is a public forum.
Comments may be monitored for inappropriate content but the newspaper is under no obligation to do so. Comment posters are solely responsible under the Communications Decency Act for comments posted on this Web site. Oahu Publishing Inc. is not liable for messages from third parties.
IP and email addresses of persons who post are not treated as confidential records and will be disclosed in response to valid legal process.
Do not post:
- Potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.
- Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
- Copyrighted materials of any sort without the express permission of the copyright holder.
- Personal attacks, insults or threats.
- The use of another person's real name to disguise your identity.
- Comments unrelated to the story.
If you believe that a commenter has not followed these guidelines, please click the FLAG icon below the comment.