Tuesday’s brutal attacks by Islamic State terrorists in Brussels and even more deadly attacks in Paris in November will roil Europe politically and culturally for years to come. But Americans must not overreact — and must appreciate that we are
Tuesday’s brutal attacks by Islamic State terrorists in Brussels and even more deadly attacks in Paris in November will roil Europe politically and culturally for years to come. But Americans must not overreact — and must appreciate that we are in a fundamentally different and safer position than many Europeans.
In Europe, the fallout was instant. Leaders of once-fringe political parties that oppose further Muslim immigration and humanitarian policies devoted to helping the refugees streaming out of Syria were quick to seize on the attacks on the capital of the European Union — as a sign of EU ineffectiveness and the fecklessness of not carefully screening new arrivals from jihadist regions.
These arguments had punch even before Tuesday’s attacks. A Financial Times analysis Monday suggested the June 23 vote in the United Kingdom about whether the nation should leave the EU might end up being a landslide instead of a close call.
The central premise of the EU — that residents can move freely among member countries without border checks — used to be a selling point. No more.
And the grim fact is there is little reason for optimism that things will get better any time soon. To the delight of the IS, a closed feedback loop has been created. Islamic terrorism in Europe leads to more scrutiny of and anger toward Muslim immigrants, which triggers jihadist sentiment, which produces allegiance to Islamic State, which leads to Islamic terrorism in Europe.
It is immensely important that this dynamic not come to the United States. We have had isolated incidents of homegrown terror by radicalized Muslims, such as the December massacre in San Bernardino, Calif. But we don’t have neighborhoods known for jihadism such as Molenbeek in Brussels, where the Paris attacks are thought to have been plotted. There are disaffected Muslims in America, yet this feeling of alienation hasn’t metastasized as it has in impoverished Muslim communities in several European nations — at least so far.
That’s why it was incendiary demagoguery for Republican president candidate Sen. Ted Cruz, after the Brussels carnage, to call for authorities to “patrol and secure Muslim neighborhoods.”
Yet even as they disavow such extreme, counterproductive rhetoric, America’s leaders from President Barack Obama on down must not appear to belittle the very real fears of Americans.
Obama might be justified in downplaying the toll of domestic terrorism and saying the Islamic State is simply not an “existential threat” to the U.S. However, after the Paris and San Bernardino attacks, a Dec. 14 Gallup Poll saw Americans identify terrorism as the biggest problem facing the nation.
This anxiety might seem extreme, but it is real, and it is fueling the rise of fear-mongering politicians such as Cruz and Donald Trump. Joel Weickgenant, managing editor of the Real Clear World foreign policy website, put it this way: “A citizenry must feel safe before it can be idealistic.”
Americans have been safe from terrorism to a remarkable degree since Sept. 11, 2001. But this truth is difficult to appreciate as we witness a mortifying “new normal” be established in Europe. Europe’s “new normal” must not become America’s. With responsible leadership, it won’t.
— The San Diego Union-Tribune
