Ruling halts commercial scooping of Hawaii aquarium fish

HONOLULU — A Hawaii Supreme Court ruling on Wednesday halts the commercial scooping of reef fish for aquariums until the state reviews the trade’s environmental impact.

The state’s practice of doling out permits for commercial aquarium fish collection must comply with the Hawaii Environmental Policy Act, the ruling said. A lower court must determine if recreational aquarium fish collection may be exempt from the law, the ruling said.

“It certainly is the biggest step forward in getting a handle on this industry, which has been virtually unregulated,” Earthjustice attorney Paul Achitoff said of the ruling. Earthjustice represented a group of divers, subsistence fishermen, environmentalists and others who sued the state in 2012. They argued there should have been environmental reviews before the state Department of Land and Natural Resources issued the permits.

Scientists estimate the aquarium trade removes about 30 million fish from reefs around the world. Hawaii accounts for less than 2 percent, while more than 70 percent comes from Indonesia and the Philippines.

In Hawaii, the brightly colored tropical fish are scooped up into nets and flown across the globe into aquariums.

The aquarium fishery off the Big Island is among the best managed in the world, scientists say. Yet there’s been a long-running conflict over whether it’s appropriate to remove fish from reefs for people’s viewing enjoyment.

“Taking tropical fish from Hawaiian reefs harms that fragile ecosystem,” Miyoko Sakashita, ocean program director for Center for Biological Diversity— one of the plaintiffs — said in a statement.

“Maybe now people will begin to realize that people are loving these beautiful fish to death.”

Each commercial aquarium collection permit authorizes removal of an unlimited number of fish or other aquatic life from Hawaii’s coastal waters, the ruling noted.

The state also issues recreational aquarium collection permits that authorize an annual catch limit of 2,000 fish for each permit.

There’s no limit on what kinds of fish are taken and how many permits are issued, Achitoff said.

“You really have this unlimited take of public resources and they’re just taken so that people can make money,” he said.

The ruling reverses lower court decisions that sided with the state.

The ruling also reverses “more than 60 years of previously unchallenged practice by the Department of Land and Natural Resources,” said a statement from Hawaii Attorney General Doug Chin. “We are reviewing the decision to determine what action the state will take in light of the ruling.”