Rep. Nancy Pelosi of California, the former speaker, recently told her colleagues in the California delegation that if President Joe Biden were to end his campaign she would favor the “competitive” process of an open primary rather than an anointment of Vice President Kamala Harris as the new Democratic presidential nominee.
In one of the delegation’s weekly closed-door meetings earlier this month, a small group of members were discussing the party’s stressful state of affairs, in which Biden appears defiant in the face of concerns from lawmakers and leaders in his own party who want him to step aside.
Pelosi, who arrived late to the meeting, spoke up in response to questions from members.
When asked about Biden, she said she did not think he could win, citing polling data, an assessment that she has shared privately with the president. Pelosi said that if he stayed on the ticket, Democrats would lose any shot they might have of winning back control of the House, according to three people familiar with the confidential conversation who insisted on anonymity to describe it.
Lawmakers in attendance then pressed her on what the landscape would look like if Biden ultimately decided to step aside under pressure. Pelosi told them she favored a competitive process. Pelosi, according to a source familiar with her thinking, is a friend and fan of Harris, a former senator from California.
But she believes even Harris would be strengthened to win the general election by going through a competitive process at the convention.
A second person briefed on Pelosi’s views, who also declined to be named discussing private conversations, said her desire for an open primary process is driven by polling data about who can win the election, and that she believes the Democratic Party has a deep bench of talent to draw from, including governors and senators in competitive states.
Pelosi’s comments at the meeting regarding her preference for an open primary were first reported by Politico.
They emerged as pressure continued to mount on Biden to withdraw from the race, and Democrats began to weigh considerations if that should occur, including what would make for the smoothest transition and who could raise the money and draw the support necessary to mount a competitive campaign.
Some lawmakers and operatives believe an open contest would generate excitement within the party, while others worry that it would alienate Black voters by seeming to circumvent Harris, a prospect they are already anticipating.
Pelosi’s private preference was echoed publicly by a close ally, Rep. Zoe Lofgren of California, someone whose statements are often understood to have Pelosi’s seal of approval, and who Friday called for Biden to drop out of the race.
“Should he make that decision, there will have to be quick steps,” Lofgren said on MSNBC after she went public with her appeal to the president. “I don’t think we can do a coronation. Kind of a mini-primary, maybe a vetting hosted by former presidents, including Obama and Clinton, would be helpful.”
Members of the California delegation were shaken Friday night by the fact that the private discussion inside their long-running party meeting had leaked. Some referred to the weekly California lunch as a “sacred space” and said the fact that the conversation was shared in the media underscored how anxious Democrats are about the uncertainty surrounding the presidential process, and the effect it will have on down-ballot races.
© 2024 The New York Times Company