By TIM BALK NYTimes News Service
Share this story

House Republicans have been told by their party’s leadership to avoid town halls after Democrats and others began to seize on the events to vent frustration with the Trump administration.

Rep. Victoria Spartz, a third-term Republican from suburban Indianapolis, decided not to heed the warning this weekend — and was met with fury over cuts to the federal government’s services and workforce.

ADVERTISING

On Friday and Saturday, Spartz hosted gatherings with constituents. And each day, she found herself in hostile territory.

She was booed, jeered and scolded over the Signal scandal at the Defense Department (she acknowledged the Trump administration needed to do a “better job”) and the Homeland Security Department’s efforts to deport immigrants without due process (she declared that immigrants living in the country illegally were entitled to “no due process”). And she was accused of standing idly by as Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency steered cuts to government services (she said the Trump administration was trying to stop fraud).

She faced chants of “Do your job!” At times, the events turned into shouting matches. Some of the exchanges have circulated widely on social media.

“You don’t have to scream,” she pleaded at a crowded town hall in Westfield on Friday night. The event lasted for two interruption-filled hours.

“I understand there’s frustration,” she said at another point, as she tried to defend Musk and DOGE.

One person in the crowd told her she did not understand her role as an elected representative. “I understand my role very well,” Spartz said. “That’s why I have these town halls.”

The crowd howled when she said she would not call for the resignation of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who shared sensitive U.S. military plans on a Signal chat, apparently unaware that the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic had been inadvertently added.

Spartz, who was born in Soviet Ukraine, also faced questions about her position on U.S. aid for Ukraine. She said that she did not support the United States’ sending a “blank check to anyone” but that “Russia has been allowed to get away with too much.”

Outside the town hall Friday, protesters who could not get inside chanted, “This is what democracy looks like.” Inside, Spartz threatened to stop hosting town halls.

But on Saturday, she was back at another one, in Muncie, facing down more angry voters.

“She’s not fulfilling her congressional duties and upholding the separation of powers,” said Josh Lowry, chair of the Hamilton County Democrats, who led protests outside the town hall Friday. “She’s selling out Hoosiers.”

Lowry said Republicans such as Spartz had won elections in November by focusing on the cost of living, but have now instead joined in Trump’s campaign of “retribution.”

“They’re all worried about Trump endorsing an opponent” in a Republican primary election, Lowry said.

Republicans are also under pressure to hold on to their razor-thin majority in the House. This past week, Trump announced that Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., was withdrawing her bid to become the United Nations ambassador. The announcement highlighted worries among Trump and his party about their ability to win what should be safe Republican seats as Democrats have shown strength in special elections this year.

On Saturday, Spartz thanked everyone who had attended her town halls, but claimed that she had been targeted by people on the far left. She said that her staff members had been spat at and that a Trump supporter was punched outside the town hall Saturday.

“The radical left is organizing to silence the truth at town halls, but we cannot let it happen,” she said in a statement. “It’s not pleasant, but I can handle their aggressive behavior.”

Christine Kassebnia, 62, a self-described swing voter who waited for more than two hours to get into the town hall Friday, bristled at the suggestion that Spartz’s critics at the events were on the far left.

“These were not far anything,” she said. “They were just people. And they’re upset.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

© 2025 The New York Times Company